EU Pay Transparency Directive and Variable Pay: What It Means for Commissions and Bonuses
How Directive (EU) 2023/970 treats commissions and bonuses: the variable-pay indicators in Art. 9, actual vs. target pay, the 5% joint assessment, a worked example and where sales comp plans create gaps.
The EU Pay Transparency Directive - Directive (EU) 2023/970 - is usually discussed as a salary-band and job-ad topic. For any company with a sales team, the bigger exposure is variable pay. Commissions and bonuses are fully covered, the pay gap report measures them separately, and they depend on inputs that are rarely documented: territories, accounts, quotas, lead routing, side agreements. This guide covers what the Directive says about variable pay, how to calculate the indicators, and where commission plans typically create gaps.
What the Directive requires - in one table
| Obligation | What it says | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Pay structures | Pay must rest on objective, gender-neutral criteria: skills, effort, responsibility, working conditions | Art. 4 |
| Before hiring | Initial pay or its range before the interview; no questions about pay history | Art. 5 |
| Pay-setting criteria | The criteria for pay, pay levels and pay progression must be easily accessible (progression optional below 50 workers) | Art. 6 |
| Right to information | Every worker can request their pay level and average pay by sex for their category; answer within two months | Art. 7 |
| Pay secrecy | Workers can’t be stopped from disclosing their pay | Art. 7(5) |
| Reporting | Seven indicators, from 100 workers, phased by size | Art. 9 |
| Joint pay assessment | A gap of 5% or more in a category, unjustified and not remedied within six months | Art. 10 |
| Burden of proof | Shifts fully to the employer if it failed its transparency obligations | Art. 18(2) |
| Compensation | Full back pay including related bonuses, damages, interest - no upper limit set in advance | Art. 16 |
| Limitation period | At least three years | Art. 21 |
Reporting timeline
| Workers | First report | Then |
|---|---|---|
| 250+ | 7 June 2027 (for 2026) | annually |
| 150-249 | 7 June 2027 (for 2026) | every three years |
| 100-149 | 7 June 2031 | every three years |
Commissions and bonuses are pay
Art. 3(1)(a) defines pay as “the ordinary basic or minimum wage or salary and any other consideration, whether in cash or in kind, which a worker receives directly or indirectly (complementary or variable components)”. Recital 21 lists bonuses among the examples. The words commission, accelerator and SPIFF don’t appear anywhere in the text, but they are consideration for work, so they’re covered.
The Court of Justice settled the principle long ago: equal pay applies to pay that depends entirely or largely on individual output (Royal Copenhagen, C-400/93), and it must be ensured for each element of pay, not just the total (Barber, C-262/88). Germany’s Federal Labour Court applied that to a field sales rep in 2023: her employer couldn’t offset a lower base salary by pointing to earlier eligibility for commission (BAG 8 AZR 450/21). “Lower base, better commission” doesn’t balance out.
The variable-pay indicators in Art. 9
| Indicator | What it measures | What it shows in a sales team |
|---|---|---|
| (b) | Gender pay gap in complementary or variable components (mean) | Whether women earn less commission and bonus on average |
| (d) | The same gap as a median | Whether a few top earners drive the gap or it’s broad-based |
| (e) | Share of women and men receiving complementary or variable components | Who never lands in commission-eligible roles or plans |
| (g) | Gap per category of workers, broken down by base salary and variable components | Whether the gap arises within the same role, e.g. among AEs |
The gap is the difference between men’s and women’s average pay, as a percentage of men’s average (Art. 3(1)(c)). The median gap uses the same formula with medians.
The Directive doesn’t say whether the variable-pay gap is calculated across recipients only or across all workers. Both are defensible; whichever you choose, indicator (e) shows who received nothing.
Worked example
A 12-person sales team: six Account Executives and six SDRs, three women and three men in each role. One female AE works 60% part-time. Figures are actual gross annual pay, scaled to full time:
| Role | Gender | Base (FTE) | Variable pay (FTE) |
|---|---|---|---|
| AE | M | €70,000 / €70,000 / €72,000 | €52,000 / €48,000 / €61,000 |
| AE | F | €70,000 / €68,000 / €68,000 | €38,000 / €41,000 / €30,000 |
| SDR | M | €45,000 / €45,000 / €46,000 | €14,000 / €12,000 / €16,000 |
| SDR | F | €45,000 / €45,000 / €44,000 | €13,000 / €15,000 / €0 |
Results for the whole team (variable-pay gap across recipients):
- Gap in base salary: 2.3% - unremarkable.
- (b) Gap in variable pay (mean): 19.0%.
- (d) Gap in variable pay (median): 6.3%.
- (e) Share receiving variable pay: women 83%, men 100%.
- (a) Overall gap (mean): 13.4%.
Per category (g), the AE gap is 15.5% overall - almost entirely commission (32.3% gap in variable pay vs. 2.8% in base). The SDR gap is 9.0%, caused by one person who received no variable pay. Both categories are above 5%. Unless the employer can justify them with objective criteria - documented territory allocation, comparable quotas - a joint pay assessment follows six months after the report.
Note how the team-wide median (6.3%) understates the problem: mixing AEs and SDRs blurs it. The per-role view shows where the gap actually comes from.
Actual pay or target pay?
For sales teams, this is the biggest open question. Two reps with the same OTE can earn very different amounts at 140% and 70% of quota.
- Recital 22 says it should be possible to base pay levels on the actual pay of the worker.
- Germany’s expert commission recommends actual pay for reporting by majority; some members wanted target pay so parental leave and part-time don’t distort the comparison (final report, in German).
If reporting is on actual pay, everything that drives payouts lands in the report: territory design, quota setting, lead routing, discretionary bonuses. And you need reliable actuals per person and calendar year, base and each variable component separately, including adjustments and clawbacks.
Where sales comp plans create gaps
The rate is rarely the problem. The inputs are:
- Territories and accounts. The same rate pays more in the richer territory. Document allocation criteria and check territory potential by gender.
- Quotas. An inflated quota costs twice in tiered plans - lower attainment and no accelerator. Document the method and every adjustment; prorate quotas for part-time.
- Lead routing and deal splits. Inbound leads and split credit move revenue without anyone selling more. Use fixed routing and split rules.
- Discretionary bonuses and MBOs. Courts don’t accept general claims of better performance. The German Federal Labour Court requires the employer to compare both people’s appraisals and disclose criteria and weighting (BAG 8 AZR 300/24, para. 44).
- Side agreements and guarantees. Negotiating skill alone doesn’t justify higher pay (BAG 8 AZR 450/21), and pay-secrecy clauses won’t keep deals hidden (Art. 7(5)).
- Leave and return. Prorating variable pay for parental leave is generally lawful; cutting a bonus for maternity leave periods is not (Lewen, C-333/97). The joint pay assessment explicitly checks pay improvements after leave (Art. 10(2)(e)).
Where the factors determining variable pay can’t be identified, the employer may have to prove it didn’t discriminate (Royal Copenhagen) - and under Art. 18(2) that’s automatic once transparency obligations were breached.
What about job ads for sales roles?
Art. 5 requires the initial pay or its range before the interview. Since pay includes variable components, a sales job ad that only lists base salary tells half the story. Until national laws settle the detail, the clearest format is: base range, variable target at 100% attainment, resulting OTE range, plus the key plan mechanics (cap, accelerator). Our OTE guide explains how base and variable add up.
A checklist for commission plans
- Every sales role is mapped to a category of workers, with documented criteria.
- Plans are written down: rates, quotas, tiers, caps, guarantees and exceptions.
- Every deviation from the standard plan has an objective, documented reason.
- Territory, account and lead allocation criteria are recorded.
- Quota methodology is documented; part-time quotas are prorated.
- Discretionary bonuses use weighted criteria, written reasoning and a second approver.
- Leave rules are compliant, and returners’ territories are a documented decision.
- Base and each variable component are available per person and year, as actual pay.
- You’ve run a trial analysis for 2026 per category, and every gap of 5% or more is explained or closed.
How Centify helps
Centify isn’t a pay equity analytics tool. It’s the source for the hardest part of the data: variable pay you can explain.
- Plans as rules: commissions, bonuses, SPIFFs, tiers, accelerators and ramps are built in the no-code plan designer, and every rep sees their plan and OTE on one page.
- Calculation trail: every payout traces back to CRM deals, including Salesforce opportunity splits; deal changes trigger recalculation.
- Approvals on record: role-based approvals with comments and an audit trail for every payout (Payout).
- Clean hand-off to payroll: payouts are exported with their wage type, so commission and bonus stay separable.
Your HR or payroll team runs the gender analysis; Centify makes sure the variable-pay column is correct, separable and traceable. For a first look, try the pay gap calculator.
FAQ
Does the EU Pay Transparency Directive cover commissions and bonuses? Yes. Art. 3(1)(a) defines pay as the basic wage or salary plus any other consideration in cash or in kind - explicitly “complementary or variable components”. Recital 21 names bonuses as an example. Commissions, accelerators and SPIFFs aren’t named, but they fall under the definition.
Which variable-pay indicators must the pay gap report include? Art. 9(1) requires the gender pay gap in complementary or variable components (b), the median gap in those components (d) and the proportion of female and male workers receiving them (e). Indicator (g) also splits the gap per category of workers into base salary and variable components.
Is the gap calculated on target pay (OTE) or on actual pay? The Directive doesn’t spell it out, but Recital 22 refers to actual pay, and Germany’s expert commission recommends actual pay for reporting. Expect reports to be based on what was really paid out, not on OTE. National laws make the final call.
When are the first pay gap reports due? Under the Directive, employers with 150 or more workers report by 7 June 2027 for calendar year 2026; those with 250 or more report annually after that. Employers with 100-149 workers report by 7 June 2031 and every three years. National laws can shift these dates.
What happens if the gap in a category exceeds 5%? If a category of workers shows a gap of at least 5% that the employer can’t justify with objective, gender-neutral criteria and doesn’t remedy within six months of reporting, the employer must carry out a joint pay assessment with workers’ representatives (Art. 10). It must cover variable components for each category.
Has Germany implemented the Directive? Not yet. The transposition deadline was 7 June 2026; as of 20 November 2026 no draft bill had been published. Germany’s 2017 Pay Transparency Act (Entgelttransparenzgesetz) still applies, and the equal pay principle of Art. 157 TFEU is directly enforceable.